• Losing the overtones
    July 16,2014
    • Email Article
    •  Print Article
    As one who grew up in a pre-computer world, I have been struck by the apparent lack of concern about what I see as a major loss — one that seems to be inherent in the current computer-generated electronic environment.

    Basically, we have lost the overtones that can add so much richness to what we do and how we do it. And I fear the loss is not simply aesthetic — we may also be losing an essential element of a diverse cultural landscape.

    Start with the basic notion of a loss of overtones. Michael Graves, a noted architect and emeritus professor at Princeton, argues in a recent New York Times article (“The Lost Art of Drawing”) that the computer, while fine for a final drawing of a finished design, loses an essential element of the creative process: The mind/hand/eye interaction between the physical act of drawing, and the conceptualization of the architect’s vision, is lost. Might there not be a similar loss involved with the apparent disappearance of cursive writing from the school curriculum? Yes, writing on computers can still require complete sentences — but there is a seemingly inescapable mechanical element.

    I would argue that the resulting banalization of expression (OMG!) extends to verbal communication — flat, uninflected nasal timbre, and to the computer generation’s seemingly universal use of stilted, pedantic pronunciation (e.g., student comes out “stew dent”). And loss/unawareness of overtones impoverishes our ability to comprehend and communicate. A particularly egregious example is the replacement of “problem” with “issue,” with a consequent loss of weight and resonance.

    Much has been made of the amazing burst of creativity/innovation the Internet and related electronic developments have enabled/engendered. But this may be a very mixed blessing if, as I suspect, we also have a flatter, less diverse landscape with fewer overtones. And a diverse environment, which produces regular, ongoing interaction among people doing different things in different ways — cities would be an outstanding example — has been widely identified as an especially rich environment for innovation.


    • Email Article
    •  Print Article
    MORE IN Letters
    Life has a way of bringing joys and sorrows. Full Story
    Why is our Vermont Public Service Board exempted from the open meeting law (1 V.S.A. Full Story
    Donald has declared that he is the “law and order” president. Full Story
    More Articles