• Suspects in 2010 slaying due in court
    The Associated Press | March 08,2014
    • Email Article
    •  Print Article
    ST. JOHNSBURY — Two of three Vermont men suspected of killing a Sheffield woman during a botched 2010 robbery of her home are due in court Monday to face first-degree murder and other charges.

    Richard Fletcher, 27, and Keith Baird, 33, are scheduled to face murder and other charges during the appearance, according to records at St. Johnsbury criminal court.

    Fletcher, Baird and Michael Norrie, 23, all of Sheffield, have been named as suspects in the shooting death of Pat O’Hagan, 78, a mother of five and grandmother of nine who disappeared on Sept. 10, 2010.

    Her body was found by hunters three weeks later in Wheelock.

    All three men are in state or federal custody on charges unrelated to the death.

    Fletcher and Baird were cited to appear in court on Monday. Norrie is being held at a federal prison in Pennsylvania after a federal conviction on gun charges. It’s unclear when Norrie will be returned to Vermont to face the murder charges.

    Court records in unrelated cases indicate Norrie, his cousin Fletcher and his brother Baird, all of Sheffield, were involved in the killing of O’Hagan. She was shot in the head.

    “It was great news for our family,” son Mark O’Hagan told the Burlington Free Press. He said the family first learned that the men were considered suspects three years ago.

    The case alarmed the normally quiet Northeast Kingdom community of Sheffield.

    Caledonia County State’s Attorney Lisa Warren did not return a call Friday seeking comment.
    • Email Article
    •  Print Article
    MORE IN Vermont News

    PLAINFIELD — Black Bear Biodiesel recently ended its first season selling... Full Story

    The State Board of Education is looking at making changes that would require greater scrutiny ... Full Story

    On a cloudless day in late September, 10 lawmakers drove to Springfield for a tour of the... Full Story

    More Articles