Vt. Supreme Court overturns drug case for searchBy WILSON RING
The Associated Press | August 03,2013MONTPELIER — A man convicted of cocaine possession was illegally taken into custody in Rutland before consenting to be searched, the Vermont Supreme Court ruled Friday in overturning his conviction.
In its decision, the court ruled that a trooper who threatened to take the man, Asim Betts, into custody while the trooper applied for a search warrant didn’t have the probable cause to do so.
Betts agreed to be searched only after he had been told he would be placed in handcuffs and taken to a Vermont State Police barracks in Rutland while the trooper applied for the search warrant.
“It is also well established that consent is not voluntary when it is a mere submission to a claim of lawful authority,” said the court’s decision.
In June 2010, Betts was a passenger in a car that the trooper had been watching after receiving a report from a confidential informant that the driver had been seen with cocaine. Several hours later the car was stopped in Rutland for a traffic violation.
The driver and Betts did not immediately agree to be searched. The trooper told them that if they would not give consent, he was “prepared to seize their persons and the vehicle to apply for a warrant.” While that was under way, he told them, the men would be handcuffed.
Later, after they had returned to the state police barracks, the trooper found cocaine outside the vehicle that Betts admitted belonged to him.
Betts was charged with felony possession of cocaine. He later reached a plea agreement with prosecutors and was sentenced to up to 60 days in jail.
He claimed he had been subject to an illegal search, but the Rutland Superior Court rejected that claim. As part of his deal with prosecutors, he reserved the right to appeal that decision.
The Supreme Court disagreed with the lower court, saying Betts agreed to a search only after the trooper said he’d be taken to police barracks to await a warrant, and that the trooper lacked the authority to take him there without cause.
“Neither the informant’s tip nor the trooper’s lengthy surveillance or later interaction with defendant provided probable cause,” the court wrote.
Vermont Defender General Matthew Valerio, whose office defended Betts, said Betts’ last known address was in Hartford, Conn. Valerio did not know whether Betts served his sentence or if Betts knew his conviction had been overturned.
While the court overturned Betts’ conviction, the case didn’t set any legal precedent, he said.
“What this does is give another set of factual circumstances to advise law enforcement and (defense lawyers) of what gives rise to probable cause in Vermont,” Valerio said.MORE IN Vermont NewsMONTPELIER — U.S. Sen. Full Story
- Most Popular
- Most Emailed
- RICHARD'S POOR ALMANACK: On this day in 1520, Ferdinand Magellan is first European to navigate passage that bears his name from the Atlantic to the Pacific sea; in 1582, Will Shakespeare, Anne Hathaway secure their marriage license with 40 pound bond.
- RICHARD'S POOR ALMANACK: On this day in 1778, Capt. James Cook is first European to set eyes on Maui in Hawaiian Islands; 1922, Pharoah Tutankhamun found after 3000 years; 1909, Hollawood movie star Frances Dee born in Los Angeles.
- TOMORROW'S HEADLINES TODAY: Hazmat unit called downtown, Boys & Girls Club hosts dinner for members and families, Secret Santa back on the beat, city discusses runoff problem on Mayfield Road, Brandon gets creative about fixes to town roads, sidewalks.
- RICHARD'S POOR ALMANACK: In 1944, U.S. begins B-29 bombing raids on Japanese main islands; in 1950, Great Appalachian Storm begins to form; 1963, Lee Oswald killed by Jack Ruby; 1974, D.B. Cooper hijacks Seattle-bound airliner; 1974, 'Lucy' found.
- RICHARD'S POOR ALMANACK: On this day in 1927, striking Colo. miners attacked with machine guns by state police; 1877, Thomas Edison announces invention of the phonograph, 1959, Alan Freed fired by WABC 770 AM for accepting payola to promote records.
- RICHARD'S POOR ALMANACK: On this day in 1863, President Abraham Lincoln delivers short speech in Gettysburg, Pa.; in 1984, a Pemex LNG facility destroyed by series of gas explosions, 600 people are killed; in 1998, Senate builds fire under Bill Clinton.