Study: Tar sands oil carries no increased risk to pipelinesBy DAVE GRAM
The Associated Press | July 04,2013MONTPELIER — Some environmentalists may be overstating fears about the corrosive effects of tar sands oil on pipelines like the one across northern New England, according to a new study published by the National Academy of Sciences.
Possible pipeline corrosion by tar sands oil has been cited by opponents of both a possible reversal of flow in the northern New England pipeline and the Keystone XL pipeline proposed to carry tar sands oil from western Canada to refineries in Texas.
Opponents say moving the oil through the aging pipeline would be a threat because it is thicker and more corrosive than the regular crude it now carries, making it more likely to spill and cause an environmental disaster.
They also say that when burned, the fuel contributes more greenhouse gas emissions than lighter crude.
In Vermont, environmental official Kirsten Sultan ruled in April that a plan to reverse the flow of the New England pipeline, which now flows east to west from Maine to Montreal, would require a new permit under state law.
The pipe’s owner, the Portland Pipe Line Corp., is asking Sultan to reconsider. On Tuesday, its lawyer, Peter Van Oot, wrote to Sultan and asked her to take into account a study released June 26 by the Transportation Research Board, an affiliate of the National Academy of Sciences.
The NAS is a private, nonprofit organization chartered by Congress to advise the federal government on scientific matters. The study said there did not appear to be increased risk from shipping tar sands oil on pipelines that otherwise would carry traditional crude oil. “The committee does not find any causes of pipeline failure unique to the transportation of” tar sands oil, the study said. The committee also said it found no aspects of the oil that would make it more likely than other crude oils to affect its transportation.
The American Petroleum Institute welcomed the findings, noting that Canadian crude oils have been transported safely in the U.S. for 40 years.
“All crude oils have to meet the same criteria when put in a pipeline, which protects the pipeline and communities along its route, as well as the quality of all transported crudes,” the API’s pipeline director, Peter Lidiak, said in a statement.
One person outspoken about perceived dangers of shipping tar sands oil via pipelines is Jim Murphy, senior attorney with the National Wildlife Federation’s Northeast regional office in Montpelier.
Murphy wrote in a blog post Monday that the study “is no surprise and provides no comfort.” He said the study did not consider several key issues, one being that when tar sands oil does leak, it sinks to the bottom rather than floating on the surface of water, making cleanup much more difficult.
“The study did not look at how this substance behaves after it spills,” Murphy wrote.MORE IN Vermont News
- Most Popular
- Most Emailed
- TOMORROW'S HEADLINES TODAY: Vermont Gas Systems puts Phase 2 on hold as the latest estimate for Phase 1 takes a 27 percent leap upward, to a total of $157 million; U.S. Attorney Tristram Coffin quits for job with private firm; police cite man in pot bust.
- RICHARD'S POOR ALMANACK: In 1972, Christmas bombing of North Vietnam ordered by President Richard Nixon, most lethal strikes of the war; in 1989, U.S. invades Panama to depose, arrest and charge Gen. Manuel Noriega with drug trafficking, racketeering.
- TOMORROW'S HEADLINES TODAY: Gov. Peter Shumlin announces demise of his single-payer health insurance initiative; convicted first-degree murderer Alan Prue sentenced to 50 years for killing teacher Melissa Jenkins; veterans chafed about park naming snub.
- RICHARD'S POOR ALMANACK: In 497 BC, first Saturnalia festival celebrated in Rome, Scandinavians retain 'Yule Goat' as symbol of season, Krampus, evil side of holiday cheer, terrorizes children into better behavior, more advice from Christopher Hitchens.
- RICHARD'S POOR ALMANACK: In 533 AD, Byzantine Emperor Justinian I gets the old empire back together again routing the Vandals from Carthage; in 1890, Lakota Chief Sitting Bull is killed at his home in South Dakota; in 1970, Soviets land probe on Venus.
- DUANE CARLETON: Rutland Herald Events Editor George Nostrand interviews musician Duane Carleton, whose new CD 'A GIRL LIKE THAT' drops Thursday, Dec. 18, 2014, and will be celebrated that evening with a show at 9:30 p.m. at Killington's Pickle Barrel.